1
Wishlist by Square
Built for ShopifySquare Apps · since 2025 · Marketing and conversion
Boost sales by letting shoppers save and buy favorites later
Rating
5.0
86
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free
Alternatives
Best alternatives to Magic Wishlist for Shopify
Magic Wishlist — Free Shopify wishlist app. Recover lost sales with back-in-stock, price drop, low stock & wishlist abandonment emails. Guest wishlists, no code.. These are the top-rated Customer loyalty Shopify apps to consider instead of Magic Wishlist, ranked by Ecomgraph rating and review data.
10 alternatives · Customer loyalty
#
App
RatingMerchantsPricing
2
Swym Wishlist Plus
Built for ShopifySwym Corporation · since 2016 · Sales channels
Enables customers to bookmark their favorite products and pick up where they left off when they return
Rating
4.7
1,428
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free trial available
3
Revamp · since 2019 · Marketing and conversion
Grow Sales with a customizable Wishlist & Email reminders
Rating
4.6
388
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free plan available
4
Growave: Loyalty & Wishlist
Built for ShopifyGrowave · since 2014 · Marketing and conversion
All-in-one retention platform with Loyalty, Reviews, Wishlist
Rating
4.8
1,239
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free plan available
5
Mascot Software Technologies Pvt. Ltd · since 2014 · Marketing and conversion
Allow customers to create and manage multiple wish lists.
Rating
4.7
153
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free trial available
6
Joy Loyalty Program & Rewards · since 2025 · Marketing and conversion
Create and manage personal wishlists - Easily add to cart
Rating
5.0
10
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free
7
TValueApps · since 2026 · Marketing and conversion
Boost sales with wishlist reminder & restock emails marketing
Rating
5.0
8
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free
8
Swish (Wishlist King)
Built for ShopifySwish · since 2015 · Wishlists
Drive revenue & delight customers with a customised Wishlist.
Rating
5.0
285
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free trial available
9
Froonze VIP Loyalty & Wishlist
Built for ShopifyFroonze Limited · since 2021 · Loyalty and rewards
Grow w/ loyalty program, rewards, cashback, customer account
Rating
5.0
263
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free to install
10
Appstle℠ Subscriptions App
Built for ShopifyAppstle Inc. · since 2021 · Loyalty and rewards
Retain customers with subscriptions, subscription box, bundles
Rating
5.0
7,703
Merchants
—
Pricing
Free plan available
Magic Wishlist alternatives — FAQ
What is the best alternative to Magic Wishlist?
Wishlist by Square is the highest-rated alternative to Magic Wishlist in the Customer loyalty category, with a 5.0 rating across 86 reviews. See the full ranked list above.
Are there free alternatives to Magic Wishlist?
Some Customer loyalty apps offer free or freemium plans. Each app above links to its Ecomgraph page where you can see normalized pricing tiers and per-plan features.
How are these Magic Wishlist alternatives ranked?
Alternatives are other Customer loyalty Shopify apps ranked by Ecomgraph data — primarily average rating weighted by review count — excluding Magic Wishlist itself.